From My Carolina Home

Quilting, cooking, reading books, gardening, crafting, sewing, photography and more


10 Comments

Sewing Fiction Magic and Ghosts

Supernatural occurrences are abundant in these books with a sewing theme. My favorite of all the writers of ghostly themes is Barbara Michaels. In fact, it was the book Stitches in Time that hooked me on her writing many years ago. Who doesn’t love a good ghost story, especially with Halloween coming up?   The first is Ammie Come Home, originally published in 1968, but you don’t need to read it to follow the story in the second two books.  The author is good about catching you up, and this book is hard to find.  It introduces the house and the family, with Ruth and Patrick.  A  spirit takes over a vulnerable woman, trying to prevent history from repeating itself.  Another more malevolent spirit has other plans.  Shattered Silk is the second book and introduces us to Ruth’s niece Karen and her friend Cheryl, who come together to open a vintage clothing store.   There no ghosts in this story, refreshing in that it isn’t a murder mystery, but I was expecting some supernatural element – it is Barbara Michaels after all! But, the mystery is engaging, difficult to put down, and there are some twists that you won’t see coming. It is fun to read a book written before the internet or cell phones (1986), which would have changed the story in some ways, as characters would not be out of touch – unless there was the story device of a dead battery or out of tower range.  These are the second and third books in the Georgetown trilogy.

Sewing Fiction Barbara Michaels ~ From My Carolina Home

Stitches in Time picks up 10 years later, with both ladies married and dealing with a thriving vintage business.  Karen has changed her name to Kara, to exorcise the memory of her ex-husband.  When a stolen quilt is left at their door, strange things begin to happen to their part time worker Rachael, eerily like something that happened before.  Patrick remembers some of the ghostly incidents (from the first book), and tries to unwind the mystery, but the curse on the quilt isn’t easily set to rest.  The descriptions of the vintage quilt are marvelous, as are descriptions of some of the vintage clothing.  There is a good deal of information on preserving and cleaning old garments and quilts in the book too. I highly recommend this series.

Annette Blair writes a cozy mystery series with magic in the clothes.  First up, A Veiled Deception as Maddie returns home to Mystick Falls, Connecticut to attend her sister’s wedding.  Things go awry when the ex-girlfriend of the groom winds up dead and the bride is the main suspect.  When Maddie begins having visions coming from the wedding dress, things get interesting.  In the second book, Larceny and Lace, Maddie is busy with her vintage clothing store, called Vintage Magic, in a building formerly the morgue.  Again, she gets visions from the clothing that helps point her to clues.  I liked both these books, there is a bit more romance in these than usual, but I can handle a little.  I have the next three yet to read.

Blair books

I have yet another magic series on Mount TBR, the Magical Dressmaking Series by Melissa Bourbon.  Harlow Cassidy, descendant of Butch Cassidy, moves back to her home town in Texas to escape the big city and open a custom dressmaking shop.  Apparently all the women in the family have special gifts, but Harlow believes that she doesn’t have any gifts.  Her mother can make things grow, her grandmother can talk to goats, and her great grandmother Meemaw always got what she wanted.  Meemaw has passed on, but apparently not left the house she left to Harlow in her will.  Ghostly occurrences and communication helps Harlow unravel the mystery, as she discovers that her gift is in the sewing of dresses and clothing to help the wearer feel better, or pretty, or more confident.  All the books have sewing tips in the back. I think I am missing book 2, but will likely just skip it and read the rest of what I already own.

Bourbon Books

So many books, so little time!  What are you reading now?

 

Sharing

Val’s Tuesday Archives

 


68 Comments

Sewing Fiction Stories About Life and Giveaway!

Continuing the series on sewing fiction,  I received an advance reader copy of Birds in the Air from the author.  I think Frances could tell by my blog that I am a quilter that reads, and asked if I would like to read her new book.  Of course, I said yes, as it was set around a quilt show in a small town in North Carolina.  Right up my alley.  Later I found out that not only is she a resident of NC, but she has been quilting for a number of years too!  I did not promise her a review, she sent it with no strings.  But guess what, it is a wonderful story.

Birds in Air

Birds In The Air by Frances O’Roark Dowell is named for a quilt block, and I had to look it up to see it.  Amazing, Tango has that basic shape in it.  The story involves a woman whose family moves to a small town in the mountains of NC.  Her husband and daughter settle in quickly with job and school, but Emma needs something to do.  Finding an old quilt in an attic trunk is the catalyst for searching out the local quilt shop.  She is not a quilter to start with, but that quickly changes.  Through a series of events, she ends up learning to quilt as well as becoming the publicist for the local guild’s quilt show.  That doesn’t sit well with some of the members who consider her an outsider.  Conflict with another guild member creates a disaster for the quilt show, and help comes from an unlikely source.  The story is interesting and told in an easy to read style, and I found it difficult to put down.  I also like that Emma is happily married, as many of these series begin with a divorce so the woman can find her own way.  I like that a married woman can also find her own way while having a family and a committed relationship.  I finished it in just a few days.  The book will be published on September 24th, and one lucky reader will get a copy from the author.  Just comment on this post. Giveaway is over.

Books with a Sewing Theme ~ From My Carolina Home

The second book to tell you about is The Florabama Ladies Auxilliary and Sewing Circle by Lois Battle. This book is also set in a small town, with a newly divorced woman moving there for a job. This book was another one where the title is misleading. There is a sewing bit in the last third of the book, but it isn’t explored as well as it could have been. The story follows the ladies as they are downsized out of jobs, and try to find their way in new situations, returning to school and finding work. The sewing circle becomes a way to make some money, but even that has a disaster that the central character should have seen coming, I sure did. It annoys me when a woman is portrayed as just being stupid, making idiotic choices. So, I cannot really recommend this one, there are better books to spend your time reading.

Sewing Fiction Series on From My Carolina Home

Then there is Miss Scarlet’s School of Patternless Sewing, but I almost wall banged this book halfway through.  That is where the book is so bad you throw it against the wall to avoid wasting any more time on it.   The dialogue is stilted, (no one really talks this way), being bludgeoned with platitudes, overly perky ‘blog posts’, and has completely unrealistic plot with an even more unrealistic conclusion. It seems to be written by someone very young and idealistic, but the world doesn’t work this way. I’m sure I’ll be branded as a “negative nellie” as stated in the novel to be ignored as someone unhappy with their life, but I am very happy with my life thank you very much.  And if you cannot handle criticism, you will never grow.  This story had so much potential, a fresh point of view and story of achieving dreams with determination, but didn’t deliver. The characters never really captured my interest. It left the impression of being a Young Adult novel written by someone who hasn’t really had any similar experience, rather than being a novel of accomplishment through hard work. After all, how many 30-year-old protagonists with two years of grunt work experience (and two degrees, really?) get made CEO of a multi-national company? NOT!! Pass this one by unless you are in your 20s. There are much better books to read.

Vintage Affair2

One of those better books is A Vintage Affair by Isabel Wolff that I reviewed last year. The book jacket describes this story as centering around a woman, Phoebe, who opens a vintage clothing store. She likes to think about the woman that owned a garment before her, what her life might have been like. When she encounters an elderly French woman who wishes to sell some of her garments, Phoebe finds a new friend with a story of her own. What the jacket doesn’t say is that both women are trying to overcome a tragedy in their lives. There is a connection between the two women in that each blames herself for circumstances beyond her control. The revelation of these circumstances to each other helps each woman to come to terms with the past and give light to the future. This isn’t a sad story, it is a beautifully written journey with hope. The descriptions of the clothes will make a textile enthusiast drool with happiness. She describes 1950s prom dresses with bustier tops and frothy net petticoat skirts as cupcake dresses. There is lovely detail in the descriptions of Vivienne Westwood skirts, a Balenciaga dark blue silk evening gown, and a pleated evening gown by Madame Gres, along with other items. It makes the reader want to visit this store and feel the fabrics, admire the buttons and peruse the hats and jewelry.  I’d really enjoy spending an afternoon there.

I recently found another book to add to Mt TBR (Mount To-Be-Read), The Dressmaker by Rosalie Ham set in 1950s.  It was made into a movie starring Kate Winslet last year, but I don’t remember seeing it in the theaters here.  It is set in Australia, and is categorized as Australian revenge comedy.  It was nominated for a number of Australian film awards and won several.

Are you reading any sewing fiction from this series of posts? Or any sewing fiction?  Comment to be entered into the drawing for a copy of Birds in the Air.  The drawing will be by random number, and will take place on Saturday morning, Eastern Daylight Time in US.  Drawing is open to readers anywhere in the world.  Drawing has been held.

If you missed the first three posts on Sewing and Quilting in Fiction, click on Quilting Fiction, Sewing Mysteries, and Sewing Fiction.

Sharing at

Rattlebridge Farm Foodie Friday and Everything Else

Whoop Whoop Friday

Crazy Mom Quilts

Val’s Tuesday Archives

 


9 Comments

Sewing Mysteries

I really enjoy the genre of cozy mysteries, nice easy to read stories without gore, overt violence, sex or foul language. Even the obligatory murder for a murder mystery happens “off camera”, and only the body is found. Arlene Sachitano writes such a series with a quilting theme. The books are written in an easy to read style, with lots of quilting thrown in. There are some tips here and there too. One tip I found particularly appropriate was that quilters usually do not have enough lights in their stash, so every time you buy fabric you should throw in a yard of a light to round out your stash. Good advice!

Sachitano

Books with a Sewing Theme ~ From My Carolina HomeThe first book, Quilt As Desired, starts out with the main character, Harriet Truman, coming back to Foggy Point so she can keep a business running while her Aunt Beth is on a cruise. Instead, she finds out after her aunt leaves that she has in fact retired and left Harriet the business and her house. When Aunt Beth’s best friend, Avanell, is murdered, and her own studio trashed, Harriet must figure out what is going on before the killer strikes again. Harriet is thrown into the investigation with Avanell’s son, Aiden, and he quickly becomes smitten with her. However, Harriet is having none of it. She is still reeling from being suddenly widowed five years earlier by a husband who didn’t tell her about his fatal illness. But the Loose Threads quilting group welcomes her and helps her to begin to heal that wound.

Books with a Sewing Theme ~ From My Carolina HomeIn the second book, Quilter’s Knot, Harriet and the Loose Threads go to a retreat. One of the members, Lauren, is attending a longer program in original design to stop the rumors of her copying other quilter’s work. However, Aunt Beth thinks she saw an identical quilt to Lauren’s work while she was in Europe. Lauren believes the school owner has in fact copied Lauren, and wants Harriet to prove it. But when the owner is killed, it is up to Harriet to prove Lauren is innocent, and she doesn’t even like Lauren.

The third installment, Quilt As You Go, has Harriet and the Loose Threads making quilts in Civil War reproductions to sell at the local reenactment and street fair. When one of the ‘soldiers’ doesn’t get up after the ‘battle’, Harriet is dismayed to find he is dead. Not only that, but he was married to one of the Loose Threads and was thought to have died 20 years ago. Of course there is a quilt involved, that appears without warning in Mavis’ house, a quilt she made for that husband years earlier and hadn’t seen since before he ‘died’. There is a lot to sort out here, including finding out about a stranger that appears to be interested in Carla, another Loose Threads member. The romance between Harriet and Aiden heats up a little too. The books are quick reads, and are printed in trade paperback size with print you can actually see. There are three more in the series, and I look forward to reading them as well.

Casey books

Elizabeth Lynn Casey’s series Southern Sewing Circle begins with Sew Deadly.  New to town, librarian Tori Sinclair becomes embroiled in a mystery, and she is a suspect.  She has the added problem of being a Yankee in South Carolina.  Joining a sewing circle to make friends, she has another problem as the former librarian is a member.  I found this book very engaging, with a wonderful easy style.  I’ve only read the first one in the series, and will get to the rest soon.

Button mysteries

Kylie Logan (one of several pen names for Constance Laux) writes a cozy series set in a button shop.   I really wanted to like this series, but the more I think about it, it just didn’t hit the bar of other cozy authors.  Josie Giancola is surprised to find burglars in her shop ransacking the place, right before she is to show a super star some button choices for the star’s wedding gown.   When the super star is later found dead in her shop, Josie has to do some digging concerning a strange button found with the body.  Josie is still attracted to her ex-husband, who is always in trouble with money and gambling, but his character gets a bit annoying.  I truly get aggravated by characters that cannot take a stand and stick with it, and Josie eventually gives in to his constant requests for money with unbelievable stories.  She calls it a payment for services, but we all know better.  She gets manipulated by a TV show host, Estelle, who wants her to be the Button Babe, a demeaning role that she eventually agrees to do.  I was also disappointed that there wasn’t more button lore in the book, there is only a website mention in the back.   I’ll read the next one just because I already have it, but if the characters don’t grow, I’ll likely not go any further.

Another cozy mystery series by Earlene Fowler called Benni Harper mysteries involves a widow who moves to a small town in California to be the new director of the Folk Art museum.  Her first exhibit is an antique quilt show.  Of course, the murder occurs there, and the police chief would rather she go back to quilting and stay out of his way.  Over the course of the first two novels, they end up together.  The fun thing is all these novels are named for quilt blocks, starting with Fool’s Puzzle, and continuing with Irish Chain and Kansas Troubles.  There are now eleven novels in the series.  I got bored with this series after book 3, and I have to say this was some time ago.  I haven’t read most of the series.

Lee books

Amanda Lee (pen name of Gail Trent) writes the Embroidery Mysteries series dealing with cross stitching.  Beginning with The Quick and the Thread, new shop owner Marcy finds the previous tenant dead in the store.  It is part of the formula, I think, that the first murder has the protagonist as a suspect, generally with the victim found in the new business, or in connection with it.  But, such are cozy mysteries!  Still, I enjoy reading them.  Next, in Stitch Me Deadly, and antique piece of needlework become the catalyst to solve the death of an older woman who collapses in the store.  I have several more to get to in this series as well.

Quilt Fiction

I have two more cozys on the To Be Read shelves, (pictured above) The Cat The Quilt and The Corpse by Leann Sweeney, and Plagued by Quilt by Molly MacRae.  I’ll get to these at some point.  Plus I just found another one at the library sale last weekend, a new series starting with Going Through the Notions by Cate Price.  Reader Barbara let me know of yet another cozy series that I haven’t seen yet – Mainely Needlepoint Series by Lea Wait.  The first book of that series is Twisted Threads, and looks really interesting as it ties the current day murder with the disappearance cold case of the protagonist’s own mother.

This is the third post in my series on sewing and quilting in fiction.  If you missed the first two, find them at Quilting Fiction and Celebrate National Sewing Month Fiction.  There will be two more posts with additional genres, and next time a giveaway!

Have you read any of today’s books?  Are you a cozy mystery fan?

Save


12 Comments

Quilting Fiction

Continuing the series on fiction with sewing and quilting themes, today we look at books with quilting as the main theme. These books are in the genre of women’s fiction, kind of a catch-all category of stories about real life, life challenges and family dynamics.

Bostwick1One of my favorite series in the genre of women’s fiction is Marie Bostwick’s Cobbled Court Bostwick2Quilts Series.  Beginning with A Single Thread, the main character is blindsided by a divorce, and takes off on a trip to Connecticut.  While she is there, she finds an old storefront, abandoned and in disrepair.  Deciding to pursue a long held dream of owning a quilt shop, she settles there and begins a new life.  Ms Bostwick tackles some tough issues in her series, each book with something to make you think.  In A Single Thread, Evelyn battles cancer.  In the second book, A Thread of Truth, the members of her quilting circle befriend an abused woman, and deals with domestic abuse.  Throughout the entire series, the small town life, and deepening friendships between the women of the quilting group endure and grow.

In A Thread So Thin, a younger member learns to know her own mind and assert herself. Bostwick3 The fourth in the series deals with economic hardship in Threading the Needle.Bostwick4 The fifth novel titled Ties that Bind delves into the life and aspirations of another quilter, who upon turning 40 tries to accept that she might always be single.  The best thing about these novels is there is no foul language, no violence, just life and all its ups and downs.  Bostwick5The reader begins to care for the characters, and reading the next installment is like visiting old friends.

I have the next one on my to-be-read pile, and plan to get to it soon.  Apart At The Seams promises to return to New Bern, and Cobbled Court Quilts with the introduction of a new character.  Gala is trying to find her way after discovering her husband had an affair.  I expect that this book will be in keeping with the series, with women supporting each other in times of crisis, finding solutions and learning about themselves.  It is definitely a series that will tug at your heart.

Bostwick

The Art of Mending by Elizabeth Berg is about a quilter who discovers a family secret.  As siblings gather for an annual reunion, the middle child reveals that she was the victim of physical and emotional abuse by her mother, but the siblings have a difficult time believing the revelation, as it is years after the events.  The siblings are in their 40s and 50s, and this comes out of the blue. What memories are real and what are imagined slights by a drama-queen personality?  Interspersed between the chapters are little reminiscences of childhood, like looking at an old photograph.  Reviews are mixed on this one on Goodreads, but I found this book engaging and interesting.  There is only a little quilting in the book, and interesting to read about her very well stocked studio, however I am not sure the author really quilts.  A couple of statements don’t make sense to a real quilter, like cutting strips of fabric 3/4-inch wide – ummm, the strip would end up 1/4 inch wide, what good would that be?  And another about applique being less expensive for a custom quilt than piecing, again, what?  Obviously, the author hadn’t done both.  But, a quote from near the beginning of the book is thought provoking.  “As for mending, I think it’s good to take the time to fix something rather than throw it away… You’ll always notice the fabric scar, of course, but there’s an art to mending: if you’re careful, the repair can actually add to the beauty of the thing, because it is a testimony to its worth.”  How true, in quilts and relationships.  There are lessons here, mainly about letting go and appreciating what is now.

Berg

I would put all the Jennifer Chiaverini books in this classification too.  In addition to the novels we talked about earlier, she has written a number of small little books, mostly around holidays.   These are sweet, easy, and quick-reading books, and all of them are just charming.  Shorter stories and short chapters make for good snack reading.  Snack reading is what my friend Patty calls just a little bit of reading when you don’t have a lot of time, like 5 minutes just before bed.

Chiaverini books

Have you read any of these books?  Are you a snack reader sometimes?

 

Sharing

Val’s Tuesday Archives

 


11 Comments

Celebrate National Sewing Month – Sewing Fiction

September is National Sewing Month, and this year I am going to take a different approach to the celebration.  Oh, not to worry, there will still be plenty of sewing this month, projects and quilts, but this time I am going to do several book reviews for fiction with a sewing or quilting theme.  When you start to look, there are a lot of books set around sewing and quilting, so I’ll have more reviews for you this month.  Just so you won’t think I am doing this all this month, I had the idea a couple of months ago and started pulling novels with this theme to get a head start.  As usual, I will give you the ones I recommend as well as the ones you should leave on the shelf.

Books with a Sewing Theme ~ From My Carolina Home

First up, The Giving Quilt by Jennifer Chiaverini.   I was surprised to read some of the other reviews and went into it thinking I might not like it.  But, for the most part, it is an enjoyable read.  Jennifer Chiaverini writes character studies, not action novels.  The backstory for the quilters who came together with one common purpose was the story.  Normally I would take longer to read, savoring each short story withing the larger convergent novel, but I just got interested.  I liked that it was set at a quilt retreat, and as I make Project Linus quilts myself, I was also happy to see that real life charity depicted.  In some ways it was difficult to read about the economic struggles and the loss of loved ones, but that is real life.  In the past this author has been criticized for not being real enough.  I didn’t take the points of view as attacks on anyone in particular or of any political view.  But then, I don’t typically go looking for a fight in the pages of a novel.  Having said that, this author is able to write whatever she wants, and if her point of view differs from mine, I hope I will heed the advice of the librarian and engage in dialogue, not just dismiss what I might not agree with.  And I hope she keeps writing.  I have enjoyed all the Elm Creek novels, not so much her historical civil war novels though.

Books with a Sewing Theme ~ From My Carolina Home

Next was A Spool of Blue Thread by Anne Tyler.   This is the first novel I have read by Anne Tyler, and it won’t be the last. Stories of family, daily living and the struggle against hardship are a nice break from mysteries. This one is just that kind of story, with characters that you like, ones you want to slap sideways, and ones you just wish weren’t part of the family. Just like my family, so I can relate. I did not care for the middle section of the book, though, as manipulative Linny and weak Junior that gets manipulated (all while knowing that he is being manipulated) irritate me to no end. I also don’t care for long sections of flashback, if you need that much time then rearrange the story and put that part first. I originally picked up this book for the title, thinking that sewing would be a part of the story, but it wasn’t. The spool of thread makes an appearance at the end as a symbol in the life of the aimless character, Denny, who maybe has a bit of insight at that point. Overall, a good story, but just four stars. I will read another Anne Tyler in the future.

Needlecraft Mysteries

Just in case you missed it, I reviewed the Needlecraft Mystery series by Monica Ferris in July. While not exactly sewing, it is set around a needlecrafting store – cross stitch and crewel are sewing of a type, aren’t they? Anyway, I like this series, and recommend it as well.

So, there are the first ones for this series on sewing fiction.  What are you reading?  Have you read any of these?

 

Sharing..

Show Off Saturday at Sew Can She

Val’s Tuesday Archives

 


11 Comments

Needlecraft Mystery Series

A nice long weekend and it looks like it is going to rain on Sunday all day, and maybe Monday too.  DH and I had planned a hike, but I think it will turn into a couple of days of sewing and reading.  Actually, those are wonderful days in my opinion!  Now is a good time to tell you about a series I have enjoyed.  It is another in the cozy mystery genre, refreshingly with an older woman in her 50s as the central character (instead of the usual mid-30s cutsie with the hunk policeman boyfriend).  Beginning with the first in the series, Crewel World, readers are introduced to Betsy and her sister Margo in a small town in Minnesota.  When Betsy’s sister is murdered in the store, Betsy is taken on an emotional roller coaster, eventually needing to do some sleuthing on her own to find the truth.  She inherits the store and has to learn how to run it with the help of the part time staff. What started out for Betsy as a refuge from a bad divorce turns into a learning experience for taking care of herself.   The neat thing is the focus on needlecrafts, not only crewel, but knitting, crochet, and cross stitch.  Each book has a pattern in it too.  Next is Framed in Lace where a skeleton is found wrapped with a piece of lace that holds a clue.  These first books are only available in paperback, and I think I donated them back to the library some years ago.  I really would rather read hardback books, I find them easier to hold and read.  As I finished books in this series, I put them on an antique shelf that is sitting on the mantle in my basement sewing space.  Books work as decor you know, as I wrote about in Decorating With Books and More Decorating With Books.

Needlecraft Mysteries

The next book in the series is Stitch in Time dealing with a damaged tapestry.  It is followed by Unraveled Sleeve where Betsy and her friend Jill go to a knitting retreat.   The fifth book Murderous Yarn, deals with antique car racing.  I found this one particularly interesting as DH has done some vintage racing in the past.  Again, a piece of needlework holds a clue to the truth.  After the second book, the books can be read out of order, as not much changes in Betsy’s life.  That is the only disappointing thing about the series.  There isn’t a lot of growth in the main character, or change in her life once her divorce is done in the first book.  I find that I am more curious about the other characters in the series and how their lives change.

I think one of the better mysteries in this series is Buttons and Bones (#14), set in a remote cabin where a skeleton is found under a linoleum floor.  This one really had a different story than the usual, dealing with events long ago during World War II, and again a needlecraft in the form of a crocheted rug is a clue to the truth.  In Threadbare (#15), a homeless woman is found dead wearing an embroidered blouse that is her will.  Another twist on the usual story, Betsy has to solve two murders that are connected.

Needlecraft Myst 2

So, you have a series of cozy mysteries with needlework.  No, they are not great literature, and sometimes the mystery is a bit too easy to solve, but after dealing with CEUs, I am ready for something a bit mindless.  I still have these two on the to-be-read pile.  And Then You Dye is book #16, and The Drowning Spool is #17.  That will likely be it for me for one series, I have too many other books to read.

Needlecraftbook covers

After a while you begin to ask, how many murders can happen in a small town?  Horrors!  And the series sometimes gets a bit stale.  Maybe that is why I haven’t picked these up.  But the last one I read was Crewel Yule, book #8, read out of order because I wanted to save it for the holidays.  I did enjoy it, so hopefully I can get back to these soon.  Perhaps I can visit Excelsior again soon, checking in with friends not seen in a while.

What are you reading now?

 

Sharing

Val’s Tuesday Archives


7 Comments

The Cookbook Collector – Book Review

I read this novel some time ago, and  posted a short review on a Goodreads. I had mixed feelings about this book, so here is an expanded review.   The Cookbook Collector by Allegra Goodman was billed as “a delicious novel about appetite, temptation, and fulfillment” yet I did not find it so.  Isn’t it funny how our expectations will color our enjoyment of a book?  Many people found the book likeable in its portrayal of a time frame.  I was looking for something else, based on the cover synopsis, so it was disappointing to me.

Cookbook Collector 1

The author says the book is about hunger for life, love, security, but the characters were superficial at best. Certainly the hunger part of the story was clear with a race between technology companies to roll out their products first, but this didn’t translate to the authors goal to portray “dreaming instead of living”. There were too many side characters and subplots that were not fleshed out. The only really enjoyable part of the story was about the cookbook collection, which amazingly was not that large a part to the overall story.

Cookbook Collector 4

So where is the cookbook collector? This part of the story is introduced halfway through the book with a collection that comes up for sale to George (an antique book dealer) after the collector’s death. He goes to see the collection which is crammed into every available space in a kitchen, all the cabinets and even the oven are full of books. George asks Jess (his assistant) to help him catalog the collection. That part of the book was interesting, with some nice descriptions of actual antique cookbooks and cookbook lore. The story slows for a while, as the author describes the notes left on the books by the original collector. Here the novel comes close to making a statement about savoring life, not just reading about it, in a scene with Jess and a peach. I suppose that is the heart of the novel, as there are peaches on the cover art. However,  I much would have preferred a full story about the collector, his unrequited love, the search for and acquisition of the antique books, and his thoughts and feelings set down in the notes paper clipped to the pages of the books.

Cookbook Collector 3

So, did I miss the point of the book? I don’t think so. I think that the author became so wrapped up in the technology part of the story that the title story was left behind. The events of the time play a role as well, and that becomes a bit of a sidetrack with the technology boom, and the dot-com bubble burst, along with 9-11. I kept thinking to myself, so when are we going to get to the cookbook collector? It was so far into the book that I began to think that there wasn’t going to be one and the title was a metaphor. When the collection finally appears, George does do some dreaming about cooking for Jess, but it is not the entire focus of the story, and shortly after we are back to current events.

Cookbook Collector 2

The author couldn’t seem to decide which story she wanted to tell. There is the technology story with meteoric rises and crashes, the antique book seller described as older yet he is only 36 when the novel begins, the dynamic between two sisters who are opposites in personality and life goals, then with a whole new mystery thrown in at the end as they search for the Jewish roots they never knew they had. It has been said that the author was a modern-day Jane Austin, but the book only has a superficial resemblance to Sense and Sensibility. There are two sisters, and one has a complicated relationship with two men, but that’s about it.

So, would I recommend this book? Yes and no. I know a lot of people just loved it, which is why I picked it up in the first place. It didn’t meet my expectations, but you might enjoy it. Just go into it knowing that it isn’t about a cookbook collector.

Have you read this book?  What did you think?